1 of 4
Breyers Smooth & Dreamy Triple Chocolate Chip
130 calories, 6g fat
"Love at first bite! The ice cream, coating, and chips are a trifecta of yummy chocolate."
—Cheryl S. Grant, research editor
2 of 4
The Skinny Cow Mint Ice Cream Sandwiches
140 calories, 1.2g fat
"For a refreshing treat, the superminty ice cream and soft, chocolaty sandwich can't be beat."
—Jennifer Ash Taylor, managing editor
3 of 4
Blue Bunny Strawberry Banana Frozen Yogurt
100 calories, 2g fat
"Major points for the great fruity flavor. It definitely doesn't taste low fat."
—Susan Hennessey, assistant photo editor
4 of 4
Weight Watchers Giant Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Bar
140 calories, 5g fat
"This huge bar gets the creamy part right, but it could use more cookies throughout."
—Cindy Heller, assistant food editor
Originally published in the August 2010 issue of Family Circle magazine.